Saturday, May 17th, 2008...1:29 pm

Biting the Hand That Feeds Other People

Jump to Comments

David Steinberg’s chapter on Foreign Assistance in Burma: The State of Myanmar goes some way in explaining the current impasse. Rangoon may be thick with foreign NGOs, but convincing an independent Burma to accept humanitarian aid has never been easy:

Yet Burma was dependent on foreign assistance, which at various junctures was essential to the economic survival of the state. Aung San had said before independence that Burma should not become dependent on foreign support, and yet it was foreign support of all kinds that was needed: military, economic, training, and technical. But assistance had to be carefully couched. For example, the US foreign assistance program requires that the united states receive an official request for aid. Yet the Burmese would not make such a request. So a compromise was made under which the United States would write a letter inquiring whether the Burmese might be interested in such a program, and they would write back indicating that they might be interested, and this exchange of correspondence was deemed sufficient to satisfy the requirements of both sides.

2 Comments

  • “Rangoon may be thick with foreign NGOs …” What planet did you live on during your tenure there? Burma has the fewest international NGOs of any country in the region. Have you never been to Dhaka or Phnom Penh or Hanoi? As you are someone who has lived in the country, your readers are counting on you to provide an approximation of truth.

  • I covered foreign and local NGOs for the paper, so I do know something about them. A huge portion of the aid money was Japanese, but organizations like Care and WorldVision had definite presence as well. Yes, Rangoon has fewer nongovernmental organizations than Phnom Penh. I’m not sure what that proves.

Leave a Reply